Bangladesh's tourism, told properly. বাংলা · English
Bangladesh Traveller

Industry Desk

1,500 tourists stranded on St Martin's for three days: trawlers got them home, so where were the state's ships?

With ships halted for three days by Cyclone Akvan, about 1,500 tourists were stranded on St Martin's Island. Most finally came back across rough seas on wooden trawlers. Why weren't Navy or Coast Guard vessels used, what did the authorities do, and what needs to change?

By Bangladesh Traveller Desk ·

Passenger ships on the Cox's Bazar–St Martin's route were halted from Thursday, 19 November, as Cyclone Akvan churned up the Bay of Bengal. About 1,500 tourists who travelled to the island on four ships on Tuesday and Wednesday were stranded there for three days. In the end, most of them had to come back across rough seas on wooden trawlers.

Storms cannot be prevented. But on the country's most popular island, where thousands of visitors are allowed each day, the question is why there was no visible government operation to bring stranded tourists home.

Three days, day by day

DayWhat happened
Tuesday–Wednesday (17–18 Nov)About 1,500 tourists go to the island on MV Bar Aulia, Karnaphuli Express, Teknaf and Malancha
Thursday (19 Nov)Warning signal at the seaports; BIWTA halts all ships
Friday (20 Nov)Coast Guard stops several hundred tourists boarding trawlers, citing safety risks and government restrictions; room rates halved
Saturday (21 Nov)With the Teknaf UNO's permission and Coast Guard supervision, hundreds return to Shahporir Dwip by trawler; four ships move out of the Bakkhali river and wait for permission; signal No. 3 lowered in the evening

Counts of how many returned on Saturday vary by source. Ajker Patrika reported that 680 people returned on 16 trawlers by 3pm, with about 900 still on the island. The Daily Star, citing the district administration, put the number still there at 500 to 600. Bangladesh Pratidin and Dhaka Mail headlines put Saturday's trawler returns at 1,300. The lack of a single official count or list is itself part of the problem.

By trawler, at half capacity

The Coast Guard called Saturday's operation a "rescue". But it did not involve any Coast Guard vessel. With permission from the Teknaf upazila nirbahi officer, local wooden trawlers left the island carrying half their capacity, with life jackets compulsory, under Coast Guard supervision. Each carried 24 to 30 passengers.

That is the puzzle. On the same sea, on the same day, wooden trawlers were allowed to sail, while four much larger tourist ships were, according to Hossainul Islam Bahadur, general secretary of the Sea Cruise Operators Owners Association of Bangladesh (SCOAB), ready and waiting for permission. Nayan Shil of BIWTA said ships would sail once the Meteorological Department gave clearance. No published statement explains why small trawlers were judged safe when larger ships were not.

Why no Navy, Coast Guard or BGB ships?

The Navy, Coast Guard and Border Guard Bangladesh all have a presence on and around St Martin's. Bangladesh Traveller's question is why their seagoing vessels were not used to bring stranded people back, especially when tourists were willing to risk trawlers. No report published between Thursday and Saturday mentions any rescue using Navy or BGB vessels, or explains why none was attempted. Any explanation from the district administration, the Coast Guard or the Navy will be added to this report.

The tourists bear the cost

  • Rooms and food: the district administration asked hotels and resorts to house stranded tourists free or at reduced rates; acting union parishad chairman Faizul Islam said Tk 2,000 rooms were going for Tk 1,000 from Friday. But tourists complained they still paid full price for food.
  • Return tickets: Rajshahi businessman Shishir Saha and three friends cancelled four train tickets and lost Tk 20,000–25,000. Pharmaceutical company official Omar Faruk Shawon, on a two-day trip with his wife and two young children, missed his bus to Dhaka. The administration says it is coordinating with bus operators, but there is no compensation.
  • Work and family: many went for two days and were stuck for five. The cost of missed work, business or family events falls on them alone.
  • The ships back: the administration asked operators to carry stranded tourists back free or at low cost. SCOAB said Thursday's ticket holders can travel later on the same ticket or get a refund.

Questions that need answers

  1. When a warning signal is up, who is responsible for evacuating stranded tourists: the district administration, BIWTA, the Coast Guard or the Navy?
  2. Was using Navy or Coast Guard seagoing vessels considered? If not, why not?
  3. If trawler crossings were too risky on Friday, what assessment made them safe on Saturday on the same sea, and why not the larger ships?
  4. Is an official daily list kept of how many tourists are on the island?
  5. When forecasts show a cyclone risk, is there any standard applied before allowing trips to the island?

What needs to change

  • An emergency evacuation plan: a written, public protocol for who moves people, on which vessels and within how many hours when the weather turns in the tourist season.
  • A standby vessel in season: a Coast Guard or Navy vessel kept ready for evacuation in the December–January peak.
  • A daily passenger list: registration for the island already exists; use it to know and publish at once how many are stranded and how to reach them.
  • Cost protection: capped room and food prices for stranded days, and free changes to return tickets.
  • A helpline: one number for stranded tourists with up-to-date ship and weather information.

Where things stand: ships back from today

Warning signal No. 3 was lowered at Cox's Bazar and three other seaports on Saturday. Citing administrative clearance, the ship operators told agents in notices that sailings on the Cox's Bazar–St Martin's–Cox's Bazar route resume on Sunday, 22 November. Karnaphuli Cruise Line will run MV Karnaphuli Express and MV Bar Aulia, and Parapar Cruise Line will run MV Teknaf.

The rules for tickets dated 19, 20 and 21 November differ between the two:

  • MV Teknaf: those tickets can be used on any day until 30 November, but passengers must tell the operator before travelling so the ticket and seat can be authorised; travel without authorisation is not allowed. Passengers on the island can return to Cox's Bazar on tickets for those dates.
  • MV Karnaphuli Express and MV Bar Aulia: passengers with 19–21 November tickets whose names are on the trip sheet can travel on 22 November. Cancellation requests for those dates are accepted only until the ship leaves on 22 November. Anyone boarding on a ticket that was already cancelled will have to pay again.

Both operators cited "administrative hassle" alongside the bad weather. Parapar Cruise Line's notice said it, too, was suffering from a lack of coordination among government offices.

If you hold a ticket for 19–21 November, confirm your date and seat with whoever sold it (your agent or the operator) before setting off, and leave a spare day before your bus or train home.

FAQ

Why were ships to St Martin's halted?

Rough seas caused by Cyclone Akvan, and warning signals at the seaports, led BIWTA to halt ships on the Cox's Bazar–St Martin's route from 19 November.

How did stranded tourists get back?

On Saturday, on wooden trawlers to Shahporir Dwip, with the Teknaf UNO's permission and Coast Guard supervision, at half capacity and with life jackets.

When will ships run again?

After the warning signal was lowered, the operators said MV Karnaphuli Express, MV Bar Aulia and MV Teknaf resume from Sunday, 22 November. Check the latest announcement before travelling.

Are tickets for 19–21 November still valid?

On MV Teknaf they can be used until 30 November with the operator's prior authorisation. On Karnaphuli Express and Bar Aulia, passengers on the trip sheet can travel on 22 November; cancellations are accepted until the ship leaves that day.

Sources

Also available in Bangla: সেন্টমার্টিনে তিন দিন আটকা দেড় হাজার পর্যটক: ট্রলারই ভরসা, সরকারি জাহাজ কোথায়?

Write for us

Send us your travel stories, guides and photos. The best are featured in the Bangladesh Traveller magazine.

Submit your story